WARNING: WATCH FOR SPOILERS!!

Belle (Emilie De Ravin) finds the mystical Pandora’s Box in Gold’s shop
Belle watches as the Jolly Roger enters a portal to Neverland. She informs every one of the situation and hands Mother Superior/Blue Fairy the cloaking spell. The dwarves lead the residents to the mines in order to find fairy dust. Once they find it, Belle casts a spell to shield Storybrooke but not before outsiders cross over the line. Gold tells Ariel to go to Storybrooke and find Belle. Ariel’s exit from Neverland does not go unnoticed by Pan. Emma, Neil, Mary Margaret, David and Hook plan to capture Pan’s shadow order to leave Neverland. Ariel arrives in Storybrooke where she meets the seven dwarves and asks about Belle. Her arrival does not go as stealthy as expected. Belle is still upset of the possibility of Gold not returning. Grumpy enters Granny’s diner with Ariel. She hands Belle the sand dollar which has a message from Gold. Henry tells Pan that he knows that his family is in Neverland. Pan tries to convince him otherwise but Henry refuses to listen. Meanwhile, Neil, Emma and Hook make plans to go to the Dark Hollow where they will be able to find Pan’s shadow. In Gold’s shop, Belle and Ariel find the item Rumpletiltskin/Gold needs to defeat Peter Pan using the tea cup Belle chipped when she lived with him in the Enchanted Forest. The outsiders, who work for Peter Pan, enter the shop and tie up Belle and Ariel. Unlike Tamara and Greg, they are fully aware of their mission. In Neverland, David and Mary Margaret are still having issues while they search for Tinkerbelle’s place. Neil, Emma and Hook journey to the Dark Hollow. Hook tells Emma that she must choose between him and Neil. They soon enter the desolate Dark Hollow.

Ariel (Joanna Garcia Swisher) and Belle (Emilie De Ravin) are tied up by two men working for Pan in Gold’s shop.
Ariel leaves Storybrooke with Pandora’s Box in hand. In Neverland, Henry comes across a tree house where he finds Wendy who is apparently ill. She tells him that the island’s magic is fading. Once Henry leaves, it is shown that Pan had Wendy lie to Henry in order for Henry to believe in him. Ariel returns to Gold and Regina and hands them Pandora’s Box. She tells them about Wendy and her brothers, and asks them to save Wendy. Regina is not sure about it but Gold assures Ariel that they will. At Tinkerbelle’s home, David and Mary Margaret inform the fairy that they have a way off the island using Pan’s shadow. Tinkerbelle does not believe them until Neil arrives with the coconut containing the shadow. Henry confronts Pan about him keeping Wendy prisoner. Pan tells him that everything she has said is true, that only the heart of the truest believer can save Neverland. He leads Henry to Skull Rock where Henry accepts his task of saving Neverland’s magic.

Emma (Jennifer Morrison, left) and Neal/Baelfire (Michael Raymond-James) head for Dark Hollow to trap Pan’s shadow
Regina questions Gold’s love for Belle after Ariel leaves for Storybrooke, assuming that he doesn’t truly love her. Gold in return questions Regina’s jealousy towards the fact that he has someone who cares for him and whom he cares for in kind. Alas, poor Regina. She wonders for a second about her love for Henry. Does he love her in return? Can he love her after the things she has done in Storybrooke especially when her mother Cora arrived? She’ll have to find out when she gets to Henry. However, there may be hope for her as she does something out of character. Before Ariel leaves for Storybrooke, Regina promises to reunite her with Eric who is in Storybrooke. Regina holds her end of the bargain when Ariel successfully returns with Pandora’s Box and she grants the bracelet the ability to allow Ariel to switch between human and mermaid at free will. Yeah, there is no double crossing from Regina. It’s a love quarrel between Hook and Neil who try to fight for Emma affections but Emma sets them straight by stating that she only cares about finding her son. With her feelings for Neil in question and her feelings for Hook nonexistent, getting Henry back is the only thing on her mind.

John (Matt Kane, left) and Michael (James Immekus, right) try to destroy Pandora’s Box in order to save Wendy who is imprisoned by Pan.